Some notes on neutral density (ND) filters

by Florian Kainz, Principal Scientist

A Neutral Density, ND, or gray filter is a sheet of partially transparent material that is placed in front of the camera lens to make a scene appear darker without changing any colors. The filter allows a specified fraction of the incoming light to pass through while blocking the rest.

ND filters come in two forms, either darkened glass, usually mounted in a round frame with screw threads; or thin, flexible sheets of tinted gelatin or plastic. The latter are often referred to as “gel filters.” Glass filters have high optical quality, and they are durable. However, mounting them on a phone requires a specialized phone case with matching threads. Gel filters are sold as rectangular sheets. They are easy to cut to any required size and shape with scissors, and they can be attached to a phone using adhesive tape. Gel filters scratch easily, but their low cost essentially makes them disposable.

How much light an ND filter transmits is specified by stating either its “density,” a number of “stops,” or a “filter factor.” Which value is given depends on the filter’s manufacturer. A density 0 filter is completely clear, transmitting all light. Increasing the density by 1 implies a reduction of the transmitted light by a factor of 10, so density 1, 2, and 3 filters transmit 10%, 1% and 0.1% of the incoming light. A 0 stops filter is also clear, but a 1-stop increase implies a reduction of the transmitted light by a factor of 2, so 1, 2 and 3-stop filters transmit 50%, 25% and 12.5% of the incoming light.

The filter factor tells you how much longer you have to expose a picture to collect the same amount of light as without the filter. If the correct shutter speed without a filter is 1/100 s and you are using a filter with a 4× filter factor, then the shutter speed required to get the same exposure is 1/25 s.

Mathematically, density is −log10(t), stops is −log2(t), and the filter factor is 1/t, where the filter’s transmittance t is the ratio transmitted lightincident light.

The following table lists approximately equivalent densities, stops and filter factors:

density stops filter factor density stops filter factor
0.312×1.8664×
0.624×2.17128×
0.938×2.48256×
1.2416×2.79512×
1.5532×3.0101024×

Some manufacturers offer variable ND filters whose density is adjustable, typically from 0.3 to 1.5 (1 to 5 stops, or 2× to 32×). While variable ND filters are convenient, their quality isn’t always great. Some models have a noticeable blue tint, and others overlay a diffuse “X” pattern onto the image, especially at the maximum density setting.

Although ND filters block visible light, many are transparent to infrared light, and unlike the human eye, digital cameras are somewhat infrared-sensitive. This can be a problem with strong ND filters (above density 1 to 1.5), where the transmitted infrared light can flood photos with a red cast that is difficult to remove digitally. Infrared-blocking neutral density (IRND) filters exist, but they are pricey. Usually it is cheaper to prevent a red cast by stacking a regular ND and a dedicated infrared-blocking filter.